Pool vs. Hot Tub: What’s the Best Option for Your Yard?

Pool vs. Hot Tub: What’s the Best Option for Your Yard?

When it comes to transforming your backyard into a relaxation and entertainment hub, few additions compare to a pool or spa/hot tub. Both offer unique benefits, but the right choice depends on space, budget, maintenance, and how you plan to use it.

Whether you're considering a refreshing swimming pool for summer fun or a cozy spa/hot tub for year-round relaxation, this guide will help you weigh the pros and cons to find the best fit for your lifestyle.

Sundance® Spa sitting in a backyard in uxbridge ontario

1. Space Considerations

How much space do you have?

  • Pools: Require a larger backyard and may need zoning permits. If you have the space, a pool can serve as a stunning focal point, perfect for entertaining family and friends.
  • Spa/Hot Tubs: More compact and versatile. They can be installed on decks, patios, or even indoors. If space is limited, a spa/hot tub might be the perfect fit.

💡 Tip: If your yard is small or irregularly shaped, consider an Above-Ground Pool as a space-saving alternative.

2. Cost Comparison

Your budget plays a key role in this decision.

Pools

✔️ Installation Cost: $30,000–$100,000+ (depending on size, material, and features)
✔️ Ongoing Costs: Chemicals, water treatment, seasonal opening/closing, electricity, and maintenance

Spa/Hot Tubs

✔️ Installation Cost: $5,000–$30,000+ (varies by features, and size)
✔️ Ongoing Costs: Lower maintenance expenses, periodic water changes, and heating costs

💡 Tip: Looking for a budget-friendly way to enhance your backyard? Check out our Spa & Hot Tub Collection for affordable options.

3. Maintenance & Upkeep

Keeping your water clean and balanced is crucial for both pools and spa/hot tubs.

Pool Maintenance

  • Requires weekly cleaning (skimming, vacuuming, and balancing water chemistry)
  • Seasonal opening and closing required
  • Higher long-term upkeep compared to hot tubs

Spa/Hot Tub Maintenance

  • Requires less frequent cleaning but still needs regular water chemistry balancing
  • Draining and refilling is needed every few months
  • Easier to maintain due to smaller water volume

💡 Tip: Not sure what products you need? Visit our Pool Chemicals & Water Care section for everything you need to maintain crystal-clear water.

A Sundance® Stream™ 13 Swim Spa steaming in a snow-covered backyard with a wooden house, steps, and outdoor seating under the winter sun.

4. Year-Round vs. Seasonal Use

  • Pools: Typically used seasonally unless you invest in a pool heater to extend use into the early fall.
  • Spa/Hot Tubs: Can be enjoyed year-round, even in winter.
  • Swim Spas: Can be used year round with a heater installed. We now carrying a variety of swim spas to fit your year round needs. Shop Swim Spas

💡 Tip: Want to extend your pool season? Consider adding a pool heater to enjoy warmer water longer.

5. Health & Relaxation Benefits

Pools

✔️ Great for exercise – Low-impact, full-body workouts
✔️ Ideal for families – Fun for kids and social gatherings

Spa/Hot Tubs

✔️ Hydrotherapy benefits – Helps with muscle recovery and relaxation
✔️ Perfect for stress relief – A great way to unwind after a long day

💡 Tip: Looking for a spa that promotes wellness? Explore our Sundance Spa Collection for the best options.

6. Property Value & Lifestyle Impact

Pools

✔️ Increases home value – A well-maintained pool can make a property more attractive
✔️ Luxury appeal – Creates an inviting outdoor entertainment space

Spa/Hot Tubs

✔️ Adds lifestyle value – More about personal enjoyment than increasing home resale value
✔️ Easier to remove or relocate if needed

💡 Tip: Want a stylish backyard upgrade or just refresh your newly aquired pool? Check out our Pool Liners for a fresh new look.

Compare

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose a Pool if:

  • You have a larger yard and want a long-term investment.
  • You enjoy swimming and outdoor entertainment.
  • You’re looking to increase property value.

Choose a Spa/Hot Tub if:

  • You want a budget-friendly relaxation option.
  • You prefer year-round enjoyment with less maintenance.
  • You need stress relief and hydrotherapy benefits
Choice

POOL

SPA/HOT TUB

Space Required

Large

Small

Initial Cost

Higher

Lower

Maintenance

More work

Less work

Year-Round Use

Seasonal

Year-round

Health Benefits

Exercise, fun

Relaxation, hydrotherapy

Property Value

Higher potential

Moderate impact

Final Thoughts

Guidance from the Pros

Finally, don't hesitate to seek professional guidance from the experts at Main Street Pools. Our team can assess your yard, discuss your needs and preferences, and help you explore the various options available. With our expertise, you can feel confident that you're making the best choice for your outdoor space. Our experienced team is committed to delivering exceptional craftsmanship and customer satisfaction from consultation through to completion. 

Whether you're dreaming of a pool, a spa/hot tub, or both, Main Street Pools is here to help you turn your vision into reality. By considering factors such as space, budget, usage patterns, maintenance requirements, and design options, you can make an informed decision that will enhance your yard and elevate your outdoor living experience. 

Get in touch with us today to begin your journey toward the backyard oasis of your dreams.

READY TO START BUILDING YOUR DREAM POOL?

Fill out the form below and we will get started on helping you make your dreams a reality.